I've now spent one entire week with the iPad and although most of both the hardware and software has already been discussed online, I feel that, considering the fact that I heralded the iPad as the future of computing (not that I've been the only one or even in the minority), I ought to at least say a little bit about my experiences with it.
First of all, what am I using my iPad for? Well, to be quite honest, I hadn't carefully thought about use cases for the iPad before I bought it, but I wasn't too surprised when I found that the iPad has now replaced my MacBook Pro for most of the things that I do at home. This includes, but is not limited to: browsing, chatting, email, instant messaging, watching videos on YouTube, reading, twittering, facebooking, and listening to music. That's a lot! So, as you can imagine, I'm using my MacBook Pro a lot less now. I feel that perhaps it's foolish to go into a list of things for which I still need my MacBook, because it is far, far too extensive. iPad is the future of computing, not the present, and it can be very few people's primary computing device. However, I have to say that the first version is very, very mature already, especially for a home user. However, as of now, it's tied to a Mac or a PC for too many things such as software updates, getting data in and out, etc. that it will be a while before it can stand alone. (iPhone OS 4 will address some of these concerns though; for example, you'll be able to send arbitrary attachments to the iPad via email.)
Is it an oversized iPhone? A lot of people have asked me this question and I really don't know what to say. Sometimes my answer is "Of course not, it's an entirely different experience", but sometimes I feel that it's almost exactly like an iPhone. A couple of examples. For me, an iPhone was never a viable device for any kind of extended activity such as reading, gaming, or chatting. Not so on the iPad. I transferred all of my RSS feeds from NewsFire to Google Reader the day after I got this thing and started using NetNewsWire on the iPad to read all my news. The text is crisp, and most importantly, large! It's an amazing reading experience. And even though it sounds corny and a lot of people have said this already, when you visit a website on an iPad, you feel one degree closer to the site. Some people have described it as having a more "intimate" feel to it. It feels good and it feels right. This was not a feeling I ever got when I was browsing sites on my iPhone because it always felt so constrained. Another thing that is completely different on the iPad is writing. I'm writing this whole entry in the Notes app on my iPad and it does not feel painful. On the iPhone, I would be screaming for a real computer with a real keyboard about two sentences into anything.
Now, when does it feel like an oversized iPhone? Mostly when you discover things like, oh, Safari still can't do a Find inside a webpage, or that you can't edit any of the song information inside the iPod app, or that I still can't type in Hindi (or for that matter, that the one RSS feed I can't read on my iPad is my Hindi news feed, because the Hindi font support is still half-baked and all the matras are messed up), or that I can't truly multitask between my IM app and a browser... the list goes on. Limitation-wise, the iPad is virtually identical to the iPhone, and it's just as annoying. And iPad users will have to wait until September or October for all the iPhone OS 4 goodies, and longer still for the makers of popular apps to adopt those APIs.
Speaking of development, the iPad is a very, very exciting platform for developers like myself. Of course, it's a pain that I will have to completely redo the UI for my app, but on the other hand, there are so many exciting things that I can do with the user experience on the iPad that I couldn't have even imagined attempting on the iPhone. It's an exciting new world out there, and I am craving for some free time to spend on developing an iPad app. Perhaps next weekend.
It's funny that I feel it hardly "relevant" to talk about the hardware just because it barely feels like it's there. I never thought the iPhone was a particularly good looking device and the same goes for an iPad. With the screen turned off, both the iPhone and iPad look like plain old black slabs. All the magic lies in the software. The one thing I feel like I just have to mention about the hardware though is the battery life. It's phenomenal! My usage pattern for the iPad is more akin to a cell phone than a laptop. With my laptop, I would never even think about leaving its power adapter behind when going anywhere. When I think of my laptop's battery, it feels more like a tiny power backup device to keep the computer from turning off while I move it from place A to place B, both of which are equipped with a power adapter. It's a completely different experience with the iPad. A single percent point of battery power seems to last forever. I think I might have charged my iPad last on Thursday night or something (it's Sunday night now). The fact that I can't even remember exactly when is remarkable. I started writing this with the iPad's battery at 9% and now it's at 4%. It's been more than an hour! (All while the music was on too.) So, when I heard that the innards of an iPad looked more like a computer strapped to a battery rather than a battery strapped to a computer, I wasn't surprised one bit.
I know I wanted to write more about the iPad, but there is so much that I'm rather glad I've forgotten all the rest of it. Otherwise, I'd be here for another three hours, tapping out paragraph after paragraph about how this device makes computing (finally!) awesome.
First of all, what am I using my iPad for? Well, to be quite honest, I hadn't carefully thought about use cases for the iPad before I bought it, but I wasn't too surprised when I found that the iPad has now replaced my MacBook Pro for most of the things that I do at home. This includes, but is not limited to: browsing, chatting, email, instant messaging, watching videos on YouTube, reading, twittering, facebooking, and listening to music. That's a lot! So, as you can imagine, I'm using my MacBook Pro a lot less now. I feel that perhaps it's foolish to go into a list of things for which I still need my MacBook, because it is far, far too extensive. iPad is the future of computing, not the present, and it can be very few people's primary computing device. However, I have to say that the first version is very, very mature already, especially for a home user. However, as of now, it's tied to a Mac or a PC for too many things such as software updates, getting data in and out, etc. that it will be a while before it can stand alone. (iPhone OS 4 will address some of these concerns though; for example, you'll be able to send arbitrary attachments to the iPad via email.)
Is it an oversized iPhone? A lot of people have asked me this question and I really don't know what to say. Sometimes my answer is "Of course not, it's an entirely different experience", but sometimes I feel that it's almost exactly like an iPhone. A couple of examples. For me, an iPhone was never a viable device for any kind of extended activity such as reading, gaming, or chatting. Not so on the iPad. I transferred all of my RSS feeds from NewsFire to Google Reader the day after I got this thing and started using NetNewsWire on the iPad to read all my news. The text is crisp, and most importantly, large! It's an amazing reading experience. And even though it sounds corny and a lot of people have said this already, when you visit a website on an iPad, you feel one degree closer to the site. Some people have described it as having a more "intimate" feel to it. It feels good and it feels right. This was not a feeling I ever got when I was browsing sites on my iPhone because it always felt so constrained. Another thing that is completely different on the iPad is writing. I'm writing this whole entry in the Notes app on my iPad and it does not feel painful. On the iPhone, I would be screaming for a real computer with a real keyboard about two sentences into anything.
Now, when does it feel like an oversized iPhone? Mostly when you discover things like, oh, Safari still can't do a Find inside a webpage, or that you can't edit any of the song information inside the iPod app, or that I still can't type in Hindi (or for that matter, that the one RSS feed I can't read on my iPad is my Hindi news feed, because the Hindi font support is still half-baked and all the matras are messed up), or that I can't truly multitask between my IM app and a browser... the list goes on. Limitation-wise, the iPad is virtually identical to the iPhone, and it's just as annoying. And iPad users will have to wait until September or October for all the iPhone OS 4 goodies, and longer still for the makers of popular apps to adopt those APIs.
Speaking of development, the iPad is a very, very exciting platform for developers like myself. Of course, it's a pain that I will have to completely redo the UI for my app, but on the other hand, there are so many exciting things that I can do with the user experience on the iPad that I couldn't have even imagined attempting on the iPhone. It's an exciting new world out there, and I am craving for some free time to spend on developing an iPad app. Perhaps next weekend.
It's funny that I feel it hardly "relevant" to talk about the hardware just because it barely feels like it's there. I never thought the iPhone was a particularly good looking device and the same goes for an iPad. With the screen turned off, both the iPhone and iPad look like plain old black slabs. All the magic lies in the software. The one thing I feel like I just have to mention about the hardware though is the battery life. It's phenomenal! My usage pattern for the iPad is more akin to a cell phone than a laptop. With my laptop, I would never even think about leaving its power adapter behind when going anywhere. When I think of my laptop's battery, it feels more like a tiny power backup device to keep the computer from turning off while I move it from place A to place B, both of which are equipped with a power adapter. It's a completely different experience with the iPad. A single percent point of battery power seems to last forever. I think I might have charged my iPad last on Thursday night or something (it's Sunday night now). The fact that I can't even remember exactly when is remarkable. I started writing this with the iPad's battery at 9% and now it's at 4%. It's been more than an hour! (All while the music was on too.) So, when I heard that the innards of an iPad looked more like a computer strapped to a battery rather than a battery strapped to a computer, I wasn't surprised one bit.
I know I wanted to write more about the iPad, but there is so much that I'm rather glad I've forgotten all the rest of it. Otherwise, I'd be here for another three hours, tapping out paragraph after paragraph about how this device makes computing (finally!) awesome.
5 comments
-
Really enjoyed reading this. Thanks
-
Great post n great review..
N yes i totally agree with the intimacy issues with the iPhone and its safari.. -
I just cant imagine how u manage to type so much on a iPad.... It really doesn't look like a comfortable device to type on...
-
I'm surprised you still use the word "computing" in the last paragraph. That word will need to be re-coined. "Connecting" perhaps is more apt since you're using it for reading and writing. I'm not sure.
-
Thanks for your good comments. I have just started using an iPad and agree with them. I find I like it much more than anticipated. I use The Qingwen dictionary all the time, and am delighted you are considering an iPad app, especially the handwriting. I eagerly await it. Thanks for your efforts, and keep up the good work!

